LED

Physical analysis and cost comparison of ten leading flagship smartphone VCSEL dies (dot projector, flood illuminator, and proximity sensor) from Apple, Huawei, Xiaomi, Oppo, Lenovo, and Intel.

Today, up to three VCSEL dies can be integrated in a smartphone. 3D recognition with the flood illuminator; the dot projector; and time of flight (ToF) for the proximity sensor are all based on VCSEL laser components. Already integrated in flagship smartphones, these functions will quickly find a home in all smartphones, causing a sharp increase in VCSEL demand.

This comparative review, conducted by System Plus Consulting, provides insights into the structures, technology, and design choices related to these components, which are at the center of innovative functions. We have analyzed and compared four dot projectors, four flood illuminators, and two ToF systems, extracted the VCSEL dies, and performed a full physical analysis.

In this report, we offer technological and economical comparisons of 10 VCSEL dies integrated by the major smartphone manufacturers (Apple, Xiaomi, Huawei, Oppo, and Lenovo) in their flagship smartphones, and by Intel in its RealSense product suite. Moreover, we cover all of the functions that require VCSEL, including dot projector, flood illuminator, and proximity sensor (ToF). The components from the three key suppliers – Lumentum, Philips Photonic, and ams (Princeton Optronics) – are also included in the report.

We show the integration of the VCSEL in smartphones, and base our analysis on full teardowns of the VCSEL dies to reveal the technological choices made by the different manufacturers. Also, we have estimated the various supply chain participants. The combined knowledge gleaned from these two groups allows us to simulate the cost of these different components.

This report contains a complete cost analysis and a cost estimate of the VCSEL. Additionally, it features a full comparison of the studied samples, highlighting their similarities and differences and their impact on cost.

 

This report’s objectives are to:

Overview/Introduction

• Executive Summary
• Analyzed VCSEL, by Function
• Glossary

Company Profile

• Lumentum
• ams (Princeton Optronics)
• Philips Photonics

Market Analysis & Supply Chain

VCSEL Integration

• Philips Photonics
  • iPhone7/STMicroelectronics ToF
  • Mate 20 Pro Flood Illuminator
• Princeton Optronics
  • RealSense Flood Illuminator
  • Phab2Pro/Infineon ToF
  • MI8 Flood Illuminator
  • MI8 Dot Projector
  • Mate 20 Pro Dot Projector
• Lumentum
  • iPhone X Flood Illuminator
  • iPhone X Dot Projector
  • FindX Dot Projector

Physical Analysis

• Philips Photonics
  • Physical Analysis
  • Process Flow
• Princeton Optronics
• Lumentum

Cost Analysis

• Philips Photonics
  • Epitaxy Wafer Cost
  • Front-End Cost
  • Front-End Step Cost
  • Back-End Hypothesis
  • VCSEL Die Cost
• Princeton Optronics
• Lumentum

Comparison

• Dot Projector Comparison
• Flood Illuminator Comparison
• ToF Comparison
• VCSEL Epitaxy Comparison
• VCSEL Die Comparison
• VCSEL Cost Comparison

• ams’ Direct Time-of-Flight Detection SPAD-Based Proximity Sensor
• Sony’s 3D Time-of-Flight Depth Sensing Camera Module
• Wafer to Wafer Permanent Bonding Comparison 2018
• Smartphone 3D Sensing Modules Comparison 2020
• Apple iPad Pro LiDAR Module
• Murata Incredible High Performance (IHP) SAW Filter
• Piezoelectric Material From Bulk to Thin Film – Comparison 2019
• ASE/Deca M-Series Fan-Out Process
• Samsung 3D V-NAND 92-Layer Memory
• 200V EPC2112 eGaN® HEMT with Monolithic Optimized Gate Driver